Winch for Daystar bumper

Kind of torn between using a Superwinch Terra 4500SR or a Smittybuilt XRC 9500. Both with synthetic line but a big weight difference. 4500 lbs should be enough pull, right??

 

They say to calculate what you need is to take the gvwr x 1.5 = what you should have at a minimum.

 

Id say double your weight to figure in resistance so roughly 3t.

 

Idk if this counts, But I'm basing my own needs on the winches that Rock Road sells for the winch bumper they make. They'll sell a Warn 8000, or a Smittybilt 9500 one with the bumper.